Can Oregonís New Women Leaders in the
Legislature Bring Economic Prosperity?
no feminism here.
At BrainstormNW, we don’t grade on the curve.
But we do
score the four leading ladies on their leadership in setting out economic
agenda. This legislative session will be, must be, about more than budgets.
Oregon’s economic recovery is, to a great extent, in their hands.
BrainstormNW asked Oregon’s new women leaders to tell us what they
would do to stimulate Oregon’s economy. Here are their answers and
our brief evaluations.
State Representative Karen Minnis, R-Wood Village, and House Speaker
The new Legislature and our governor-elect’s primary goal next session
must be Oregon’s economic recovery. While there are many important
policy issues that will be debated next session, none are more important
than creating jobs and getting Oregonians back to work.
For all the talk by politicians about creating jobs, it must be remembered
that government itself does not create jobs. What government can-and should-do
is make Oregon a place where businesses and entrepreneurs will want to
What can government do to turn Oregon around? A lot. We must restore the
state’s fiscal health (What is the Fiscal Cliff?) and lay the foundation for a better-managed
Oregon. Before we ask taxpayers for any more of their hard-earned dollars,
they must be confident that their money is being used wisely. That’s
why we need to reform the state’s budgeting process, fix the Public
Employees Retirement System (PERS), streamline the state’s permitting
process and direct our transportation dollars to improving our ports,
airports and road and rail infrastructure.
First, we must end the current service level method of budgeting. It is
no wonder that state government continues to grow exponentially when state
agency budgets for the next biennium are always the last biennium’s
budget plus more for assumed growth. That assumption has been false: government
doesn’t need to grow. If there is any silver lining to our current
fiscal crisis, it is the opportunity it provides us to conduct an in-depth
review of all government services and programs and fund only what Oregonians
deem essential and affordable within existing revenues.
Second, we must reform the Public Employees Retirement System (PERS).
With an unfunded liability of $15.7 billion, PERS threatens to bankrupt
not just the state, but counties, cities, school—and other public
service—districts across Oregon. As it is currently structured,
PERS cannot be sustained. Just a month ago, the PERS Board announced that
public employers would see their PERS rates go up 37 percent beginning
July 1. That’s just this year’s increase.
That means schools will have fewer dollars to put in classrooms, police
and fire departments will have fewer dollars available to keep public
safety professionals on the job, and cities and counties across Oregon
will have to decide which services to cut just so they can pay the pension
costs of their employees. The system must be repaired not just for the
sake of taxpayers but to ensure the security of public employees’
retirement accounts. Governor-elect Kulongoski has said PERS reform will
be a priority for his administration and I look forward to working with
him to make PERS reform a reality.
Thirdly, we must streamline the permitting process in Oregon. One of the
biggest complaints I hear from business leaders is that getting the necessary
permits to open a business or begin a construction project in Oregon takes
too long. The state should set up a one-stop-shopping service for permitting,
coordinating the permits required from state and local governments to
speed up the approval process for opening a business or beginning construction.
Fourth, we cannot expect to attract industry to Oregon if manufacturers
cannot efficiently move their goods to market. We need to channel our
transportation dollars to revitalize our ports, airports, highway and
rail systems so Oregon manufacturers can remain competitive in the global
As past experience has proven, higher taxes and new government programs
won’t create jobs-they’ll only make our situation worse. Oregon
currently leads the nation in all the wrong areas: the highest unemployment,
among the worst in job creation, and lagging other states in entering
economic recovery. We can turn this situation around and put Oregon on
the road to recovery by making it a place that taxpayers and investors
alike will recognize as accountable and responsible.
The Editors’ Response:
As Speaker of the House, Rep. Karen Minnis is second only to the governor
in political power in the state. To the Speaker’s credit she notes
that the other policy issues must be subservient to the critical task
of economic recovery. However, she spends as much time discussing the
budget (PERS and spending limits) as she does on her two points for economic
recovery: streamlining the permitting process and improving our transportation
infrastructure. Our advice is to leave the problems of the budget to Rep.
Miller (co-chair of Ways and Means) and focus 90 percent of your attention
on economic recovery. Leadership requires bold action. Grade: B-
State Senator Kate Brown, D-Portland,
and Senate Democrat Caucus Leader
A Blueprint For Oregon’s Economic Recovery
There is little question this recession has been more painful for Oregon
than just about any other state. If there’s a silver lining, it’s
the opportunity to learn from it-just as we did in the 1980s when we worked
to diversify our economy.
We can start with a few big-picture issues: diversifying a tax base that
relies on a single, very volatile revenue source; reforming the Public
Employees Retirement System; addressing the impact of the rising cost
of health care on our citizens; fundamentally changing the state’s
budgeting process; and continuing to make state government more efficient
and effective while scrutinizing how it serves Oregonians.
While those “macro” changes are extremely important, they
may not make an immediate impact on Oregon’s economy. So we should
consider, simultaneously, short-term changes that can create desperately
needed jobs right away and help turn Oregon’s economy back in the
Our highest transportation priority must be relieving congestion and repairing
our aging roads and bridges, which are hampering businesses’ ability
to move supplies and products. While everyone in Salem agrees on the magnitude
of the problem, raising revenue to pay for it is another matter. It is
my hope that the legislature can find a solution early in the 2003 session
so we can start putting Oregonians back to work.
I agree with Gov.-elect Kulongoski that we should review the focus of
the Economic and Community Development Department and concentrate on attracting
and expanding business in Oregon. The department has done an admirable
job in strengthening the infrastructure in communities around the state,
but in these tight budget times we should focus our efforts on immediate
Streamlining our permitting processes can also have an immediate impact
by helping companies fill jobs faster. Setting specific timelines for
approval/denial and requiring clear and objective standards can go a long
way to erase what some perceive as an anti-business climate in the state.
We could also undertake efforts, like those in New York state, where several
permits are consolidated into a single point-of-entry for business, thus
expediting needed projects and creating jobs throughout the state quicker.
Another possible option to expedite permitting processes is pre-permitting
key building sites. Having shovel-ready sites for construction provides
a valuable marketing tool the state can use to attract new business and
jobs. Streamlining the process can provide the predictability and fairness
businesses need, and still maintain the quality of life standards that
Finally, we have to work hard and be creative in
looking for new opportunities. The Oregon Council for Knowledge and Economic
Development, created by
the legislature in 2001, will be proposing a number
of good ideas to help rebound our economy. Creating “signature”
research centers that can utilize discoveries from our state’s research
institutions and help develop products that will support the growth of
emerging markets is one such idea. Another is refocusing the missions
and curriculum of our universities to support the state’s knowledge-based
Perhaps most importantly, we must change how state government operates
and send loud and clear signals to the business community inside and outside
the state that Oregon is ready to be a productive partner in economic
To start with, I’d like to see the governor become the state’s
most active salesperson. Maintaining good schools through stable funding,
adequately funding higher education and community colleges (including
workforce training), and enacting the efficiencies and budgeting changes
as mentioned above. In addition, the state should intensify its focus
on retaining existing businesses, recruiting new ones and targeting specific
industries in recruitment.
Finally, the legislature must be careful not to make excessive program
cuts. New studies show-and one of the legislature’s chief economists
agrees-that millions of dollars in cuts can be very detrimental to the
Getting our economy on the right track certainly will not be easy, but
a leaner, smarter, and more open state government that leverages Oregon’s
tremendous assets would be a very effective start.
The Editors’ Response:
Sen. Kate Brown will share power in an evenly divided state senate. While
she references “macro solutions” for government, she did “get”
the assignment and spent the majority of her efforts on real solutions:
transportation infrastructure, refocusing the Economic Development Department
on job recruitment and retention, streamlining the permitting process,
creating “shovel ready” industrial sites, and enabling research
centers. Most importantly, Sen. Brown notes that it is about “attitude”
and she urges the governor-elect to become the state’s “chief
salesperson.” Missing is any reference to assistance to rural Oregon?s
natural resources industry. Grade: B+
State Senator Beverly Clarno, R-Bend
and Senate Republican Caucus Leader
As the 2003 Oregon Legislative Session approaches, legislators will be
walking a tightrope as they must both balance the budget and stimulate
Oregon’s economy. Current economic data show no job growth for the
past year, while the latest revenue forecast projects a budget shortfall
of nearly two billion for the upcoming biennium-over 17 percent of the
entire 2001-03 state budget. These are unenviable times at the state capitol.
Oregon benefited in the 1990s from a huge revenue boom in the high-tech
industry, tremendous growth in capital gains, and large increases
in lottery revenue, all of which resulted in unprecedented spending and
However, it is evident that the economic downturn adversely affected our
once infallible high-tech industry, and coupled with the demise of the
timber and agricultural industries, we are now left without a stable revenue
Consequently, we are faced with one of the highest unemployment rates
in the country.
Unfortunately, businesses are exiting Oregon along with their precious
jobs to other states and countries where wage demands and permit and regulatory
delays are less cumbersome. This trend must stop. In order to rebound,
we must work together to pass legislation that will retain current businesses
and attract new businesses, investors and jobs. Oregon businesses are
the backbone of our economy and we must be committed to bringing in more
dollars to Oregon rather than sending them out.
In addition, the Public Employees Retirement System (PERS) must be reformed
with the help of our unions. Their cooperation is vital to any solutions
that will occur in PERS. The increasing cost of PERS is already taking
its toll-as it will cost Portland public schools an additional $8 million
next year. That is equivalent to eight days of school or 132 teachers.
Now more than ever we desperately need to bring government spending in
line with expected revenues. Additionally, we need to stimulate the economy.
The following two-pronged approach is my recommendation to get Oregon’s
economy back on track.
STIMULATE OUR ECONOMY
· Eliminate the capital gains tax.
· Allow state and federal sustainable yield harvesting and reduction
of fuel load of our forests without three-year costly appeals.
· Revamp the Economic Development Department to focus on creating
· Direct the Department of Transportation
to build toll roads and bridges with public/private partnerships.
· Privatize government operations such as
the state motor pool, Oregon Liquor Control Commission, prisons, Oregon
Youth Authority, printing and publishing, and the Department of Motor
Vehicles among others.
· Grant tax exemptions to private retirees, equalizing taxation
on pensions, which will increase consumer spending.
· Eliminate the inheritance tax.
CONTROL AND REDUCE
· Require the Department of Human Services to follow audit recommended
· Require initiatives to receive proportional signatures from all
congressional districts prior to appearing on ballot.
· Redirect the one percent art mandate in all government constructions
· Replace the PERS board with private sector retirement fund managers.
· Statutorily restrict the growth of all government, which would
include any costs associated with voter passed initiatives.
· Reduce by 75 percent all in-state and
out-of-state travel as well as dues and subscriptions.
· Require the Oregon Health Plan to follow audit recommendations
including eligibility and other cost containment measures.
· Replace PERS with defined contribution plan for new hires.
· Provide legislative oversight of lottery functions.
· Pass legislation for statewide teacher salary schedule similar
to Washington state model.
my plan will require the joint efforts and cooperation of the public and
We live and prosper in a market-based economy that offers us enviable
freedoms and possibilities. With those liberties
there exists a delicate balance between government intervention and the
of our market economy. My goal this legislative session is to protect
that balance while stimulating a sagging economy.
The Editors’ Response:
Sen. Bev. Clarno is the other half of the senate power-sharing duo. Sen.
Clarno’s list of initiatives includes the all-important revitalization
of our natural resources industries. Oregon could have avoided the depths
of its recession had it implemented any reasonable timber harvesting strategy
and protected its forests from the devastation of last summers fires.
Given that Sen. Brown’s list lacks reference to a rational timber
policy, the challenge for Sen. Clarno will be to educate Sen. Brown about
the people, places and industries of rural Oregon. Sen. Clarno spent 1/3
of her response on rehashing the past, 1/3 on balancing the budget, and
1/3 on economic recovery. The issue is economic recovery-it should occupy
most of your time. Grade: B-
State Representative Deborah Kafoury,
D-Portland and House Minority Leader
Wake up, Brainstorm. It’s not exactly newsworthy that women will
have leadership roles in the 2003 Legislature. I mean, it’s 2003,
not 1953. Women have been playing key roles in the Oregon Legislature
for quite some time. (Yawn. Your magazine is sooooo yesterday.)
That said, let’s get down to business. Talk
to me in May and I may be singing a different tune, but right now, I’m
in a take-no-prisoners mood for a no-holds-barred, wild-bear-wrestling-match
of a session. I love my state too much to allow anything else.
So sharpen your pencils, let’s go down the list and check off the
land mines one by one.
· PERS strings. In the five special sessions (migraine, anyone?)
we survived this past year, politicians were dancing around PERS like
summer campers running from a skunk.
“You can’t touch PERS in an election year,” we were
told. Guess what? The election is over. Here’s what we do: Put new
mortality tables into law; replace the entire PERS Board and design a
new, financially sane plan for new hires. Bang. You’re done. The
only thing hard about this is actually doing it. Where there’s political
will, there’s a way.
· Smart spending. One thing you’re going to hear ad nauseam
between now and the beginning of session is this refrain:
“Legislators face a $1.8 billion deficit.” Who says? How about
this for a concept? Live within your means. That means pay as you go.
No borrowing. The state’s credit line was maxed out during those
special sessions last year and we need to heed the advice of any sober
consumer credit counselor: rip up your credit card. Mark my words, the
borrowers will be out in force again this year and I personally will stand
up to them and say, “Sorry, cash only.” (And no more accounting
tricks. Those maneuvers simply shift debt onto our future. Where’s
the responsibility in that?) Lawmakers (including yours truly) must hold
the line on new programs or tax breaks until our current crisis is resolved.
We can design the state budget from the bottom up and put the money we
have where it’s needed most.
· Schools to jobs. Are you angry about the economy? Want to do
something about it? Invest in schools. Almost every Oregon businessperson
I talk to says the number one problem facing our state’s economy
is the decline in our public schools. Jobs and schools go together-like
the song says, “You can’t have one without the other.”
Without an educated work force, new employers don’t want to move
here. Without good schools, employers who are already here want to move
away. If we want good jobs, we must have good schools.
We can do
this. It won’t be easy, but hey, great generals are never made in
Women in charge in Salem? That’s right: women who tackle the toughest,
thorniest problems. If you’re coming to the Capitol the next six
months, put on your work boots, roll up your sleeves and cinch up your
belts. No whiners allowed.
Rep. Deborah Kafoury is the house minority leader who has presided over
a continuing decline in her party’s numbers. She chose to use her
space to take offense on behalf of women (we suggested that the fact that
women will lead all four factions of the legislature was newsworthy and
that apparently offended her) and discuss the budget rather than address
the issues of economic recovery. She missed an opportunity but then maybe
she doesn’t understand what drives an economy. (P.S. Rep. Kafoury?s
PERS solution will not save a dime?or enough dimes to make a difference.)
Economic Recovery is Job One.
Producing a balanced budget will not cure the economic problems of Oregon.
Speaker Minnis has wisely delegated budgetary functions to Rep. Miller,
and Sens. Brown and Clarno would be well served to make similar delegations.
Economic recovery requires the full attention of leadership and leadership
requires bold action. It’s time to get after it.